Section 4.3 Key Hazards: Liquefaction (Group A), Chemical Hazards (Group B - MHB), Fire, Oxygen Depletion

Section 4.3 Key Hazards: Liquefaction (Group A), Chemical Hazards (Group B – MHB), Fire, Oxygen Depletion

While the IMSBC Code categorizes cargoes into Groups A, B, and C, it is the specific hazards associated with these groups, and sometimes overlapping them, that demand the Master’s and crew’s utmost attention. A failure to understand, anticipate, and mitigate these key hazards can lead to rapid and devastating consequences. This section delves into the mechanisms, risks, and critical precautions associated with liquefaction, the diverse chemical hazards presented by Group B cargoes (often referred to as MHB – Materials Hazardous only in Bulk), the ever-present risk of fire, and the insidious danger of oxygen depletion.

1. Liquefaction (Primary Hazard of Group A Cargoes):

Liquefaction is one of the most notorious and feared hazards in bulk carrier operations, responsible for numerous vessel losses and fatalities. It is a phenomenon almost exclusive to certain fine-particled mineral cargoes classified as Group A in the IMSBC Code.

The Mechanism of Liquefaction:
1. Particle Structure and Moisture: Group A cargoes consist of fine particles. When moisture is present, it fills the voids between these particles. Initially, friction between the particles allows the cargo to behave as a solid mass.
2. Compaction and Vibration: During a sea voyage, the continuous motion of the ship (rolling, pitching, heaving) and vibrations from the main engine and machinery cause the cargo particles to compact. This compaction reduces the void spaces between particles.
3. Pore Water Pressure Increase: As the voids reduce, the water within them is squeezed. If the water cannot escape, the pore water pressure (the pressure of the water in the voids) increases.
4. Loss of Shear Strength: When the pore water pressure rises to a point where it equals or exceeds the inter-particle frictional forces, the particles effectively become suspended in the water. The cargo loses its shear strength and behaves like a dense, viscous liquid, even though its overall moisture content may not have changed.
5. Flow State: The cargo is now in a “flow state” and can shift en masse with the ship’s movement.
Consequences of Liquefaction:
1. Rapid Cargo Shift: Once liquefied, a significant portion of the cargo can shift almost instantaneously to one side of the hold during a roll.
2. Severe List: This sudden shift creates a large transverse shift in the vessel’s center of gravity, leading to a severe and often unrecoverable list.
3. Loss of Stability (Free Surface Effect): The liquefied cargo behaves like a liquid with a free surface, drastically reducing the vessel’s effective metacentric height (GM) and its ability to resist heeling moments.
4. Capsize: With stability critically impaired and a severe list, the vessel can capsize very rapidly, often leaving little or no time for the crew to abandon ship.
Critical Factors:
1. Moisture Content (MC): The most critical factor. If the MC is below the Transportable Moisture Limit (TML), liquefaction should not occur.
2. Transportable Moisture Limit (TML): An empirically determined value representing the maximum moisture content at which the cargo is considered safe for carriage in a conventional bulk carrier.
3. Particle Size Distribution: Finer cargoes are generally more susceptible.
4. Voyage Duration and Weather: Longer voyages in rough seas increase the amount of compaction and vibration, raising the risk if the MC is near or above the TML.
Visual Indicators of Potentially Excessive Moisture (Cautionary Signs – Not Definitive Proof of Liquefaction Risk):
1. Cargo splattering or flattening out when loaded or when grabs are dropped onto it.
2. Presence of free water or very wet patches on the surface of the stow.
3. Cargo taking on a “soupy” or excessively fluid appearance during loading.
4. Important Note: The absence of these visual signs does not guarantee the cargo is safe. The TML and MC certificates are the definitive guides. A “can test” (described in the IMSBC Code) can be performed by the crew as a supplementary check if there are concerns, but it is not a substitute for proper laboratory testing and certification.
Master’s Unwavering Responsibility:
1. NEVER load a Group A cargo if its certified Moisture Content (MC) equals or exceeds its certified Transportable Moisture Limit (TML), unless the vessel is “specially constructed or specially fitted” for carrying such cargoes as per Section 7 of the IMSBC Code, and all associated conditions are met. This is a non-negotiable safety rule.
2. Thoroughly scrutinize TML and MC certificates for validity, date of testing, and issuing authority.
3. Be aware of weather conditions prior to and during loading that might have increased the cargo’s moisture content after testing (e.g., heavy rain on uncovered stockpiles). If in doubt, insist on re-testing.

2. Chemical Hazards (Primary Hazard of Group B Cargoes – MHB):

Group B cargoes, also referred to as Materials Hazardous only in Bulk (MHB), present a wide spectrum of chemical hazards. The specific hazard(s) vary greatly depending on the cargo.

A. Self-Heating and Spontaneous Combustion:
1. Mechanism:
  1. Oxidation: Many organic materials (e.g., coal, agricultural products like seed cake, fishmeal) and some inorganic materials (e.g., Direct Reduced Iron – DRI) can react with oxygen in the air (oxidize). This reaction is exothermic, meaning it produces heat.
  2. Biological Activity: In some organic cargoes (e.g., grains, woodchips if moist), microorganisms (bacteria, fungi) can proliferate, and their metabolic processes generate heat.
  3. If the heat generated is not dissipated faster than it is produced, the temperature of the cargo will rise. This can lead to a runaway thermal reaction, eventually reaching the ignition temperature of the cargo or flammable gases it may emit, resulting in fire.
2. Contributing Factors: Cargo type, particle size (finer particles have more surface area for reaction), moisture content (can promote biological activity or some chemical reactions), ambient temperature, temperature of cargo at loading, pile size (larger piles retain heat better), presence of contaminants, and ventilation practices.
3. Consequences: Fire within the cargo hold, potential structural damage, emission of toxic and flammable gases, and in confined spaces, explosion if flammable gases accumulate.
4. Preventative Measures and Monitoring (as per individual IMSBC Code schedules):
  1. Temperature monitoring of the cargo during loading and throughout the voyage (using thermocouples, temperature probes, or remote sensors).
  2. Appropriate ventilation strategies (often surface ventilation to remove heat and gases, but avoiding through-ventilation that could supply oxygen to a deep-seated fire).
  3. Ensuring cargo is properly weathered or aged if required (e.g., for some coals).
  4. Avoiding stowage near heat sources.
  5. Awareness of the cargo’s history (e.g., has it been wet? Has it been in stockpile for a long time?).
5. Examples: Coal (various ranks have different propensities), Direct Reduced Iron (DRI – especially Form A and B), Petroleum Coke (uncalcined), Seed Cake, Fishmeal, Woodchips, Hay.
B. Emission of Flammable Gases:
1. Mechanism:
  1. Some cargoes inherently release flammable gases (e.g., methane from coal).
  2. Some cargoes react with moisture (in the cargo or from humid air) to produce flammable gases (e.g., DRI reacting with water to produce hydrogen).
2. Consequences: If the concentration of flammable gas in the hold atmosphere reaches its Lower Flammable Limit (LFL) and an ignition source is present (e.g., static discharge, electrical spark, prohibited smoking, hot work), an explosion or fire can occur.
3. Preventative Measures and Monitoring:
  1. Regular monitoring of the hold atmosphere for flammable gases using calibrated gas detectors.
  2. Effective ventilation to keep gas concentrations well below the LFL (typically below 25-50% of LFL as a safety margin).
  3. Ensuring all ventilation openings are fitted with flame screens of the correct mesh size and that these are clean and intact.
  4. Strict prohibition of smoking, naked flames, and non-intrinsically safe electrical equipment near cargo holds or ventilation outlets.
  5. Proper grounding/bonding procedures if there’s a risk of static electricity.
4. Examples: Coal (methane – CH₄), Direct Reduced Iron (DRI – hydrogen – H₂), some metal wastes.
C. Emission of Toxic Gases:
1. Mechanism:
  1. Some cargoes inherently release toxic gases (e.g., carbon monoxide from self-heating coal).
  2. Some cargoes react with moisture or air to produce toxic gases (e.g., some metal sulphide concentrates can release hydrogen sulphide – H₂S – or sulphur dioxide – SO₂).
  3. Decomposition of organic matter can produce toxic gases (e.g., carbon dioxide – CO₂, hydrogen sulphide).
  4. Residues from fumigation (e.g., phosphine – PH₃ – from aluminium phosphide used for grain fumigation).
2. Consequences: Serious health hazards to crew, including irritation, poisoning, chemical asphyxiation, and death, even at low concentrations for some gases.
3. Preventative Measures and Monitoring:
  1. Regular monitoring of the hold atmosphere for specific toxic gases relevant to the cargo being carried, using calibrated gas detectors.
  2. Strict adherence to enclosed space entry procedures, including thorough ventilation and atmosphere testing before any entry.
  3. Use of appropriate Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) when entering spaces known or suspected to contain toxic gases, or during emergencies.
  4. Awareness of the symptoms of exposure to specific toxic gases.
  5. Following specific ventilation requirements in the IMSBC Code schedule for the cargo.
4. Examples: Metal Sulphide Concentrates (H₂S, SO₂), some types of Coal (CO, H₂S), Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizers (if decomposing – oxides of nitrogen, ammonia), Ferrosilicon (phosphine, arsine if impurities present and wetted), fumigated cargoes.
D. Corrosivity:
1. Mechanism: Some cargoes are inherently corrosive to steel, or become corrosive when wet. The electrochemical reaction leads to wastage of the ship’s structure.
2. Consequences: Damage to hold plating, frames, brackets, tank tops, and other steel structures. This can weaken the vessel over time, lead to costly repairs, and contaminate subsequent cargoes if rust scale is dislodged.
3. Preventative Measures:
  1. Ensuring hold coatings are intact and in good condition.
  2. Thoroughly drying holds before loading corrosive cargoes, if appropriate.
  3. Preventing water ingress during the voyage.
  4. For some cargoes (e.g., bulk sulphur), a lime wash coating may be applied to hold surfaces as a protective barrier (though this has environmental considerations for disposal).
  5. Awareness of the cargo’s corrosive properties from the shipper’s declaration and IMSBC Code.
4. Examples: Sulphur (especially when moist, forms acidic compounds), Salt (hygroscopic and corrosive when wet), some Fertilizers, Coal (can be acidic if sulphur content is high and moisture is present).

3. Oxygen Depletion:

This is an insidious and often fatal hazard that can occur with a wide range of cargoes, including some Group B and even some Group C cargoes. It is not always associated with an obvious chemical reaction or smell.

Mechanism:
1. Oxidation of the Cargo: Many cargoes (e.g., ores, metal concentrates, coal, forest products, grains, scrap metal) slowly react with oxygen in the air within the confined space of a cargo hold, consuming the oxygen.
2. Biological Activity: Respiration by microorganisms in organic cargoes (grains, woodchips) consumes oxygen and produces carbon dioxide.
3. Displacement by Other Gases: Some cargoes may emit other gases (e.g., CO₂ from decomposition, nitrogen used for inerting) that displace the oxygen.
Consequences:
1. Asphyxiation: If the oxygen level in a confined space drops below a safe level (typically considered to be below 19.5-20.9%; normal air is ~20.9% oxygen), anyone entering that space can rapidly lose consciousness and die from asphyxiation. This can happen very quickly and often without any warning symptoms, as humans cannot sense a lack of oxygen.
Preventative Measures:
1. NEVER enter an enclosed space (including a cargo hold, even if seemingly empty or carrying “safe” cargo) without following strict Enclosed Space Entry Procedures. This is paramount.
2. Thorough Ventilation: Before entry, the space must be thoroughly ventilated with fresh air.
3. Atmosphere Testing: The atmosphere must be tested by a competent person using a calibrated multi-gas detector to confirm:
  1. Oxygen content is at a safe level (e.g., 20.9%).
  2. Flammable gases are below the LFL (e.g., less than 1% LFL).
  3. Toxic gas concentrations are below their Threshold Limit Values (TLVs) or Occupational Exposure Limits (OELs).
4. Continuous Monitoring: If entry is prolonged, continuous or frequent re-testing of the atmosphere may be necessary.
5. Use of SCBA: If the atmosphere cannot be confirmed as safe, or if there is any doubt, entry must only be made using an SCBA.
6. Rescue Procedures: Have established rescue plans and equipment ready for enclosed space emergencies. Untrained rescuers rushing in without SCBAs often become additional casualties.
7. Warning signs should be posted at access points to spaces that may have oxygen-deficient atmospheres.
Examples of Cargoes Prone to Oxygen Depletion: Most ores and concentrates, coal, DRI, grains, seeds, wood products (logs, pulp, pellets, chips), scrap metal, some fertilizers. Essentially, almost any cargo hold should be treated as potentially oxygen-deficient until proven otherwise by testing.

4. Fire (General Hazard):

While self-heating leading to spontaneous combustion is a specific Group B hazard, fire can also occur with other cargoes or from external sources.

Sources:
1. Self-heating of Group B cargoes (as discussed).
2. Flammable gases from Group B cargoes being ignited.
3. External ignition sources (e.g., sparks from hot work, smoking, faulty electrical equipment) acting on flammable cargoes (e.g., woodchips, sulphur dust) or packaging.
4. Some Group C cargoes, while not chemically hazardous in themselves, can be combustible (e.g., wood pulp, some plastics in bulk).
Prevention:
1. Adherence to IMSBC Code precautions for specific cargoes.
2. Strict enforcement of “No Smoking” and hot work permit procedures.
3. Good housekeeping to prevent accumulation of dust or flammable debris.
4. Proper maintenance of electrical equipment.
5. Ensuring fire-fighting equipment is ready and crew are trained (covered in FFA section).

Analysis for the Master (Key Hazards): The Master’s understanding of these key hazards is fundamental to proactive safety management.

Risk Assessment: For every cargo, a thorough risk assessment must be conducted, considering the information from the shipper, the IMSBC Code schedule, and the specific conditions of the voyage and vessel.
Procedural Adherence: Strict adherence to IMSBC Code requirements, company SMS procedures, and industry best practices for cargo handling, ventilation, monitoring, and enclosed space entry is non-negotiable.
Crew Training and Awareness: The Master must ensure that all crew members, especially those involved in cargo operations or emergency response, are aware of the specific hazards of the cargo being carried and are trained in the relevant safety procedures and use of monitoring/safety equipment.
Emergency Preparedness: Have contingency plans in place for dealing with emergencies related to these hazards (e.g., cargo fire, liquefaction event, gas leak). Conduct realistic drills.
Vigilance and Monitoring: Continuous vigilance and regular monitoring (temperatures, gas levels, cargo appearance, bilge soundings) are essential throughout the voyage.
Documentation: Accurate recording of all monitoring data, ventilation activities, and any incidents or concerns is vital.

By demystifying these key hazards and emphasizing the practical steps for their prevention and mitigation, the Master can significantly enhance the safety of bulk carrier operations. This knowledge is not just theoretical; it is applied daily to protect lives, the vessel, and the environment.

← Section 4.2 Shipper's Declaration and Cargo Information Section 4.4 Testing Procedures and Certificates of Analysis →